Subscription Plus

Subscription Plus vs Shopify Subscriptions: Which is the right fit for your Shopify store?

Explore the differences between Subscription Plus and Shopify Subscriptions to discover the perfect subscription solution for your Shopify store.

5 minutes, 11 seconds

Subscription services are becoming increasingly popular in the world of e-commerce, offering customers convenience and value while providing businesses with predictable, recurring revenue. 

Choosing the right subscription app for your business can be a challenging task. To make this easier for you, we will compare two subscription apps: Subscription Plus and Shopify Subscriptions

Both offer unique features designed to enhance the subscription experience for both store owners and customers. But which one is the right fit for your store? Let's dive in and compare these two to help you make an informed decision.

Key Features

At their core, both Subscription Plus and Shopify Subscription share some fundamental features essential for any subscription service. These include options for customers to manage their subscriptions - like modifying, skipping, pausing, or canceling their plans. 

Both apps allow for various discounting methods on subscriptions and provide crucial insights through analytics on subscription activities. They also ensure customers are kept in the loop with email notifications about their subscription orders.

Subscription Plus: The Ultimate Solution for Dynamic Subscription Models

Subscription Plus is designed to cater to a wide range of subscription needs, making it a versatile choice for businesses looking to offer more than just the basics. Its features are geared towards providing a highly customizable and user-friendly experience.

Advanced Customization

With options like prepaid plans, product swaps, and adding multiple one-time items, Subscription Plus offers unparalleled flexibility. This means customers can tailor their subscriptions to their changing needs and preferences, enhancing satisfaction and loyalty.

Personalization and Engagement

The app's ability to tag customers and create subscription plans based on these tags allows for highly personalized subscription experiences. Businesses can offer targeted subscriptions based on customer behavior, increasing engagement and retention.

Operational Efficiency

Features like custom cancellation reasons and store owner notification emails for various triggers (like low inventory or payment method issues) equip businesses with the tools to manage their operations more effectively and proactively address potential problems.

Global Reach and Accessibility

With its multi-language capabilities and multiple widget styles, Subscription Plus breaks geographical and language barriers, making it easier for businesses to expand their reach and cater to a global audience.

Exclusive Features

Unique offerings such as membership-based subscriptions and SMTP email configurations set Subscription Plus apart, providing tools for niche subscription models and enhanced communication strategies.

Extensive Integration Tools

With its strategic set of integrations, Subscription Plus is well-equipped to handle the complex needs of modern e-commerce subscription services. 

From payment gateways like PayPal Express,, and Shop Payments for secure transactions to Hulk Mobile App Builder for mobile commerce, and Sky Pilot for digital subscriptions, Subscription Plus integrates seamlessly.

Shopify Subscriptions App: Simplicity and Seamless Integration

Shopify Subscriptions, while more streamlined, offers key strengths in its simplicity and integration. It is an ideal solution for Shopify store owners who prefer an easy-to-use, straightforward tool.

Ease of Use and Integration

The app's direct integration with Shopify's ecosystem makes it incredibly user-friendly. Businesses can set up and manage their subscriptions with minimal effort, making it a great choice for those who value simplicity.

Customer Convenience

Allowing customers to modify or skip their subscription orders directly from their accounts, the app offers a degree of flexibility that can enhance customer satisfaction. This feature is particularly beneficial for customers who appreciate having control over their subscription choices.

Language Support

With its multi-language capabilities, Shopify Subscriptions ensures that language barriers do not hinder the customer experience, broadening the potential customer base for businesses.

Basic but Effective Analytics

While it may not offer the depth of analytics found in more advanced apps, Shopify Subscriptions provides essential insights that can help businesses track and understand their subscription performance.

Comparison table

Comparing Merchant Experiences: Subscription Plus vs. Shopify Subscriptions

In comparing customer responses to Subscription Plus and Shopify Subscriptions, it's evident that Subscription Plus enjoys a more favorable reception, boasting an overall rating of 4.5 based on 40 reviews. Customers praise its user-friendly platform, integration capabilities, and exceptional customer support, highlighting its effectiveness in managing subscriptions and enhancing operational efficiency. 

On the other hand, Shopify Subscriptions, with an overall rating of 3 from 36 reviews, is noted for its limited functionality, customization options, and mobile formatting issues. Users comment on the app's inability to meet specific needs, such as selecting charge dates and offering multiple shipping options, indicating a need for further development to match the versatility and support found in Subscription Plus.

Subscription Plus merchant reviews

Conclusion: Which App Suits Whom?

For businesses looking for a comprehensive, feature-rich subscription solution, Subscription Plus is the clear winner. Its wide array of features, coupled with the ability to cater to a diverse range of subscription models and customer preferences, makes it a versatile choice. Particularly for stores aiming for a global reach or those requiring advanced customization and operational control, Subscription Plus stands out.

On the other hand, Shopify Subscriptions, with its simplicity and seamless integration, is well-suited for stores that are new to subscriptions or those who prefer a straightforward, no-frills approach within the Shopify environment.

However, when it comes to offering a more enriched, flexible, and personalized subscription experience, Subscription Plus takes the lead. Its superior customization options, coupled with its ability to adapt to various business models and customer needs, make it a more favorable choice, especially for stores looking to scale and diversify their subscription offerings. With better reviews and a more comprehensive feature set, Subscription Plus is poised to enhance your subscription service, ensuring both customer satisfaction and business growth.


1. Which app offers more customization options for subscription plans?

Subscription Plus provides a broader range of customization options, including prepaid plans, product swaps, and adding multiple one-time items to orders, making it more versatile for businesses looking to offer personalized subscription experiences.

2. Can I integrate payment gateways easily with both apps?

Yes, both apps allow for easy integration with major payment gateways. Subscription Plus offers integrations with PayPal Express,, and Shop Payments, while Shopify's Subscription App seamlessly integrates with Shopify's payment solutions.

3. Which app is better for global businesses targeting a diverse customer base?

Subscription Plus is better suited for global businesses due to its multi-language capabilities and multiple widget styles, helping to cater to a diverse, international customer base.

4. For businesses interested in referral marketing, which app provides better support?

Subscription Plus integrates with ReferralCandy, adding a powerful tool for leveraging referral marketing to enhance customer acquisition and retention strategies.

Close Cookie Preference Manager
Cookie Settings
By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage and assist in our marketing efforts.
Strictly Necessary (Always Active)
Cookies required to enable basic website functionality.
Made by Flinch 77
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Cookies Preferences